Best 16" Electric Skillet - Guide & Reviews

Sometimes a small or even midsize electric skillet just won’t cut it for your needs. Maybe you want to offer a casserole for a church supper.

Or perhaps you want to prepare a large breakfast for your family without someone having to wait for their food to be cooked.

When that’s the case, you need the best 16 electric skillet you can get. This means that you have ample space, since one side is 16 inches long while it’s also at least 12 inches wide.

The nice thing about this kind of large skillet is that you can stir the ingredients inside easily, without having to worry that some of the ingredients will go overboard. It also makes it easy for you to flip the food over.

While the extra room works great to let you cook and serve more food, the extra size doesn’t make it all that much harder to carry from one area to another. At 12 by 16 inches, it’s still compact and still lightweight enough for a single person to carry.

Electric Skillet

So which of the 16-inch electric skillets should you pick?

Here are the top contenders:

1. Presto 06857 16-inch Electric Foldaway Skillet

1.	Presto 06857 16-inch Electric Foldaway Skillet

This is the bestseller not just among 16-inch skillets, but among electric skillets of all sizes. It’s just that good.

It’s very versatile, as it can grill, fry, roast or even bake. The aluminum base offers a very effective heating base.

As it heats up quickly and then the heat is spread very evenly across the cooking surface.

With the master heat control, it can reach and maintain the temperature you want inside. The transparent tempered glass also lets you check the food while you keep the heat in.

It also comes with a built-in spout where you can pour liquids though without having to lift the lid. That’s a big deal, since lifting the lid lets out the heat. That spout also works as a holder for the spatula when you’re cooking and as a holder for the serving spoon when it’s laid out on the buffet table.

It’s not just its size that that makes it work well as a server for the buffet. The handles on the sides and on the lid stay cool no matter what. And the see-through lid also lets people know what’s inside more easily, so that there’s no need to lift the lid and let the heat out just to find out what kind of dish is inside.

It’s easy to clean, and storage is a snap. Just about every customer who has used this has commented on these attributes. And the price is very reasonable too. So it’s very easy to understand why so many people want it and like it a lot.

2. Presto 06852 16-Inch Electric Skillet

2.	Presto 06852 16-Inch Electric Skillet

This is even more affordable than the first Presto we have on this list. It looks very different too.

While the other one has that inoffensive boxlike shape.

This one comes with curves on the sides to function as handles and legs for the electric skillet. There’s no doubt that it looks stylish and great.

Of course, it has more than its looks going for it. It comes with a nonstick coating for both the interior and exterior surfaces. What this means is that the cooking isn’t just easier, but the clean up too.

In some days, it may be just a matter of wiping it down with a damp cloth. But if you want, you can always just take it off the heat control component, and you can put both the pan and the lid inside the dishwasher.

The inside is 3 inches deep, with rounded corners so you don’t get nasty food bits stuck in the corners. It’s deep and big enough to fry 12 ounces of bacon and you’ll still get a lot of space to move the pieces around.

The lid is made of tempered glass, so it’s very durable. It’s transparent, so again you don’t need to open the lid to see what’s inside. This is very convenient when you’re cooking or when serving a dish on the buffet table.

Since the heat stays in until you really need to lift the lid to take some food. The handle of the lid will stay cool even if the food is very hot, which improves the safety immeasurably. The same goes for the handle on the sides.

It’s very durable too. We’re not just talking about the material here, but the way it works. Many owners have attested in their customer reviews that even after 3 years, the skillet still works well and reliably.

The nonstick coating is especially long-lasting too. All in all, it’s so good that even couples love it despite its 16-inch size. You never really know when you have to cook for company, right? And with this one on the buffet table, everything seems to look so much better.

3. Presto 06850 16-inch Electric Skillet

Presto 06850 16-inch Electric Skillet

Here’s another Presto skillet. The thing with skillet is that their insistence on producing a high quality product isn’t limited to just a few models. It’s pretty much across the board.

While this is another 16-inch electric skillet from Presto, again we have a different look, and this time the lid isn’t glass at all.​

For some people, that’s actually a good thing. Some don’t like the comparatively heavy weight of a glass lid. Others aren’t really fans of glass lids since they have lots of kids, so a plastic lid seems more sensible. And the plastic also allows for a domed lid, so you can put just a little bit more food inside.

Of course, the downside is that you have to lift the lid to see what’s inside. But even its opaque nature can be an advantage, if you have some people dieting in your family. And you know what they say—out of sight, out of mind.

4. Oster CKSTSKFM05 16-Inch Electric Skillet

Oster CKSTSKFM05 16-Inch Electric Skillet

This is a very handsome skillet look, as it’s decked out all in black with metal highlights around the rim and along the sides of the base connecting the legs.

It works very well for a wide variety of dishes.

From eggs, bacon, French toast and pancakes for breakfast, so making casseroles and cooking a stew.

All you need to do is to put some cooking oil in and your ingredients, and then you can turn the dial to the temperature you want. Once it reaches the temperature, it stays there due to the temperature probe. You won’t even have to remove the lid to check the food, as the tempered glass is transparent.

The handles keep cool and the whole thing can be placed in the dishwasher once you remove the probe. The cooking surface has a nonstick coating, and it will last for a very long time. So will this electric skillet, for that matter.

5. Oster CKSTSKFM-1216R 12-Inch by 16-Inch Electric Skillet

5.	Oster CKSTSKFM-1216R 12-Inch by 16-Inch Electric Skillet

This too comes with a fairly unique look. The handles are ample so you get a good grip and you have a nice balance between angles and curves.

Then you see he legs, and you have short pegs that somehow seem cute and different.​

You’re not limited to just one color however, even though the handle and legs will remain black. But you can have the pan come in red or black.

In fact, using this for the buffet table is a great idea. It’s not just because of the size, but also because the glass lid is see-through so people can see what you’re offering without lifting the lid. This helps keep the food warm inside, and it’s more sanitary too.

This model has had some trouble in the past—the 2012 reviews haven’t been especially kind—but then Oster made sure to fix the problems so the same issues no longer come up. Now you have an electric skillet that works as it should.

It heats up quickly and evenly, the handles stay cool, and the cleanup is easy. You can rest the temperature at simmer, or pick a setting from 220 to 420 degrees F. Designed for daily use, it will last you for quite a while.

Conclusion

When you’re preparing and serving food for more people, a small 12 by 12 skillet simply won’t do at all. It’s not fair when you prepare a great dish and some people don’t get a taste. And it takes too much effort and time to prepare a second batch.

So instead, get the best 16 electric skillet for your kitchen. It doesn’t add much to the occupied space on your buffet table or kitchen countertop, but it does offer a lot of convenience when you’re cooking for family, friends, and gatherings.

Even when you’re just cooking for yourself, the extra space gives you more elbow room to work with.

Nyomi Lee
 

Nyomi Lee is the Editor of ElectricSkilletUser.com. She is a cooking enthusiast and loves to share what she knows about this field. In personal life she is the mother of two kids and loving wife of a wonderful husband. She loves cooking and nothing is more satisfying than reading cookery books in his spare time.